Scholar: Media Causes
Hatred of Poor
By
Tammi McElroy
In the recently published ``Why Americans Hate Welfare,''
Yale professor Martin Gilen accuses the media of racially stereotyping
blacks as lazy and unmotivated recipients of welfare. He argues that the
media's misrepresentation of the poverty-stricken has created a new class:
the "undeserving poor."
Blacks only represent a third of those Americans
receiving public aid. Does this mean that the others two-thirds, the white
Americans, are the deserving poor? And would Americans' perception of the
welfare program be different if poverty were not depicted as a black problem?
The author examines these questions and suggests
that welfare has become a "code word" for race. His research has led him
to believe that Americans are not opposed to government support for the
needy, but for needy blacks. An example of this is the fact
that most middle-class Americans think welfare spending
should be cut but support public housing, government funded day care, Head
Start and job training programs.
The media's portrayal of black welfare recipients
as unmotivated has lead to the widespread belief that they would rather
sit home than work for their benefits. One survey showed that only 31 percent
of Americans believe that most of those on welfare who can work actually
seek employment, Gilen asserts.
The author uses Time, Newsweek, and U.S. News and
World Report to examine how the news media has portrayed poverty over the
past 45 years. He finds that African-Americans have been over represented
in pictures of the poor since the early 1960s. And that poor blacks have
been used to illustrate stories about waste, inefficiency or abuse of welfare.
Photographs of whites have illustrated anti-poverty programs.
Gilens also examines television news coverage between
1969 and 1992. He finds ABC, NBC and CBS nightly news programs have portrayed
the poor as predominantly black and that most television images of African-Americans
have come from the urban ghettos. However, there are only 6 percent of
blacks living in this subgroup of the poor, he says. While visual representation
of black poverty is the norm, news coverage during times of widespread
sympathy for the needy has left black faces noticeably absent.
Gilens reaches back into America's history of slavery
and blames slave owners for negatively stereotyping blacks to justify their
own non-abolitionist attitudes.
He accuses the media of subliminally distributing
these unflattering characteristics about African-Americans for the last
four decades. He argues that the media has turned positive public opinion
about the welfare program into negative opinions about the black race. |